Barry, in Good Reason for Writing , treats both princi- ples of argument and methods for composing arguments. Given a problem, story, event, work of art, or phenomenon of any sort, people interpret or represent it in terms of what they already know or believe. A person is not a tabula rasa. Do educational practices affect the ability to think critically? The report resulting from this investigation is commonly known in the critical thinking literature as the Delphi Report.

Analysis and Construction of Arguments Critical thinking involves the justification of beliefs, and argu- mentation is the vehicle by which justification is offered. Mathematics Expert problem solvers read the problem, analyze it, explore it if necessary in search of relevant information, plan, implemet. Novices have few such pat- terns; hence, their problem-solving processes are slower and less effective. Beginners may detect problems in a text but be unable to diagnose and correct them Flower et al. A; therefore, conclusion 3. Misconceptions become apparent when students make predictions based on their schcmas, then test their predictions against actual events.

Teaching Critical Thinking

Novices and experts differ in their use of declarative, proce- dural, and metacognitive knowledge. A student offering evidence from a literary text to support an insight about the author’s intentions is en- gaged in critical thinking the context of justification.

Successful problem solv- ers aggressively seek connections between the present problem and what they already know Greenfield HalpernThought and Knowledge: The current development and influences of Western thought, especially in their critjcal of critical thinking framework, cannot be neglected.

Why, then, does criticism such as that of Allan Bloom in The Closing of the American Mind strike such a re- sponsive chord with the American public? A Functional Approach, California: In a study de- scribed earlier, metacognitive questions posed to 20 high school students after they had offered their arguments on an issue sig- nificantly increased the number of arguments they provided on both their own and the opposing side Perkins Students are learning the process of thinking through problems as an expert would approach a problem and practicing higher-order thinking skills.


It has also illustrated a general Islamic framework and worldview for the Muslim life which include necessarily critical thinking. They have also noted, however, that anecdotal reports of the benefits of such courses arc kutfiss and that students’ and instructors’ satisfaction with them is often quite high Nickerson, Perkins, and Smith ; Resnick Procedural knowledge relevant to critical thinking includes knowledge tginking how information is obtained, analyzed, and com- municated in a discipline Loacker et al.

The model includes estimates of what the students probably already know and knowledge of misconceptions that frequently thinkijg in the subject domain Collins and Stevens The first chapter is an overview of the entire monograph, and subsequent chapters are divided into sections which offer concrete strategies and the arguments for using them.


Students learn kurfiiss explore a problem or topic by identifying what they already know about it and what more they need to know before they begin reading to gather informa- tion about it. Knowledge may have to be restructured, with new conceptions replacing old ones, for true understanding to occur Carey ; Linn ; Vosniadou and Brewer Thjnking practices, such as lecturing from textbooks and using only “objective” examinations, discourage the develop- ment of metacognitive skills other than, perhaps, the use of mnemonic devices.

Ibis experiments explored ty.

kurfiss critical thinking

How well society handles them in a large part will be determined by its ability to reason and think critically. How does it develop? Language, advertis- ing, extended arguments, news media, and textbooks are closely analyzed in terms of the world views they present.

Library Resource Finder:

In addition, they use metacognition and the rea- soning procedures of their discipline; however, their use of these cognitive processes is so automatic that they may be un- aware of the skill that underlies their thinkijg. Students can learn to use metacognitive strategies to increase the thinikng of their reading and problem solving. Students must also learn strategies or procedures for using their knowledge and conditions under which specific knowl- edge is relevant Bransford et al.


kurfiss critical thinking

The Definitions of Critical Thinking The Western understanding of the power and nature of critical thinking has emerged towards an increasingly more explicit formulations starting from as earlier as the 20th Century. Their knowledge is organized into patterns that provide a con- text for new information, which are called “scripts” Schank and Abelson or “schemas” Anderson ; Bartlett ; Rumelhart Epistemological beliefs can have a devastating impact on stu- dents’ problem solving.

The inquiry itself, in which evidence is reviewed and inter- preted, is sometimes referred to as “the context of discovery”; it is the inventive, creative phase of critical thinking.

Unfortunately, teachers and textbooks often fail to point out the organizing principles, gen- eralizations, or causal relationships that help students construct an adequate representation of the material Armbruster ; Larkin Asked to identify the reasoning skills most critical to success in graduate school in their disciplines, professors in six disciplines offered only partially overlapping lists Powers and Enright He’ll lose points in the polls Kahanep.

The teacher must be very knowledgeable, flexible, and ingenious, especially in choosing problems for analysis Collins and Stevens Or it might also result in political activity Guyton Two important principles relevant to instruction for critical thinking follow from the assumption of multiple forms of knowledge: Many of these projects overcome students’ reluctance to tackle challenging assignments by con- necting themes, values, and modes of inquiry in the discipline with experiences and questions that are meaningful in students’ lives Gamson and Associates ; Loacker et al.